Damage Formula
In Heroes of Might and Magic 3 a stack's damage is its damage roll times the number of creatures, plus 5% for each point of Attack over the target's Defense (up to 400% of base) or minus 2% for each point under (down to 30%), by the official 1999 guide. So 20 Swordsmen kill 5 to 7 Royal Griffins, worked through here.
In Heroes of Might and Magic 3 a stack's damage is its creature's damage roll times the number of creatures in the stack, raised by 5% for every point the attacker's Attack is above the target's Defense, to at most 400% of the base, or lowered by 2% for every point it is below, to no less than 30%. That is the "Damage Calculation" of Prima's official strategy guide (p.168), written for the 1999 game, The Restoration of Erathia, which is also the game inside the 2015 HD Edition. By that rule 20 Swordsmen do 126 to 189 damage to Royal Griffins and kill 5 to 7 of them; the working is below, with three more battles.
Next: the Attack, Defense, Health and Damage of every unit to put into the formula, what Offense, Armorer and Archery give at each level or turn order, retaliation, morale and sieges around the hit.
The five steps
The guide lists them in this order (p.168):
- Base damage. One random number from the creature's Damage range, times the number of creatures in the stack. A creature with a single Damage value, such as the Archangel's 50, always rolls it.
- Attack against Defense. Each point of Attack over the target's Defense adds 5% of base damage; each point under takes 2% away. The result is "modified damage".
- Bonuses, one at a time. Luck, a creature's special attack and the like are each worked out from modified damage separately.
- Sum. The bonuses are added to modified damage, not multiplied into each other, to give final damage.
- Apply. Final damage comes off the target stack one creature at a time: the first must die before the next is hurt.
The Attack and Defense used are not only the creature's own. "A Hero's Attack and Defense skill ratings are added to the Attack and Defense ratings, respectively, of the creatures in his or her army" (p.14), which is why a hero with high Attack makes even Pikemen hit hard.
Alex_The_Magician shows the sum on screen in his Jan 24, 2021 "Heroes 3 Stats explained": his Archangels have a base Attack and Defense of 30, his hero Tazar adds 14 Attack and 21 Defense, so in battle they fight at 44 and 51, and from there "it is going to be your attack versus their defense" on every hit, with each point of difference worth 5% of damage.
The table, and where it stops
The guide prints the multiplier for differences of -10 to +10 (p.169). The first five rows below are the guide's; the last four are ours, carried on by the same 5% and 2% steps to the limits the guide states.
| Attack minus Defense | Damage |
|---|---|
| -10 | 80% |
| -5 | 90% |
| 0 | 100% |
| +5 | 125% |
| +10 | 150% |
| +20 | 200% |
| +60 or more | 400%, the maximum |
| -20 | 60% |
| -35 or less | 30%, the minimum |
The guide's wording is "to a maximum of 400 percent" and "to a minimum of 30 percent". Its own table calls +10 "150 percent", a share of base damage, so we read the cap as four times base damage, reached at 60 points, and the floor as 30% of base damage, reached at 35 points.
One thing falls out of the two step sizes: a point of Attack is worth two and a half times a point of Defense. An army 10 points ahead does 150%; an army 10 points behind still does 80%.
Four battles worked through
Creature figures are the guide's for The Restoration of Erathia (pp.128-129): Swordsman, Attack 10, Defense 12, Health 35, Damage 6-9; Royal Griffin, Defense 9, Health 25; Archangel, Attack 30, Defense 30, Health 250, Damage 50. Heroes have 0 Attack and Defense unless stated, and no bonus applies. The arithmetic is ours.
| Attack | Base damage | Difference | Final damage | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Swordsmen on Royal Griffins | 120 to 180 | +1, so 105% | 126 to 189 | 5 to 7 Griffins die |
| The same, under a hero with 5 Attack | 120 to 180 | +6, so 130% | 156 to 234 | 6 to 9 Griffins die |
| 30 Swordsmen on Archangels | 180 to 270 | -20, so 60% | 108 to 162 | No Archangel dies |
| 5 Archangels on Swordsmen | 250 | +18, so 190% | 475 | 13 Swordsmen die, the 14th is left on 15 Health |
The last two rows are the same matchup from both sides. Thirty Swordsmen cost 9,000 gold and cannot kill one Archangel in a blow, because the 20-point gap cuts them to 60% and all of it lands on a single 250-Health creature. Five Archangels answer with 475 and remove 13 of the 30. That is the formula's lesson for a new player: against a high-Defense stack, small creatures need numbers or a hero's Attack before they are worth sending in.
Bonuses add, they do not multiply
The guide's own example is a Dread Knight stack whose attack comes to 100 modified damage and then gets both Death Blow and a Luck bonus, each of which doubles damage. The target takes 100, plus 100 for Luck, plus 100 for Death Blow: "a total of 300 points in final damage", not 400 (p.169).
The hero skills that change damage, in the same guide: Offense adds 10%, 20% or 30% to hand-to-hand damage at Basic, Advanced and Expert (p.19), Archery adds 10%, 20% or 30% to ranged damage, and Armorer takes 5%, 10% or 15% off damage received (p.17). Alex_The_Magician, a Heroes 3 creator, gives the same top figures in his skills overview of Feb 23, 2020: Offense "at expert level it's 30%", Armorer "only by 15% at the highest level", and he ranks Armorer below Offense. By the guide's adding rule, 100 modified damage with Expert Offense and a lucky strike would be 100 + 30 + 100 = 230; that sum is our application of the rule, not a figure the guide prints.
What halves damage (p.167): a shooter fighting hand to hand, and a shot marked with the Broken Arrow, at far range or over an obstacle. What doubles it by chance (p.165): Luck, at 4.2%, 8.3% or 12.5% a strike for +1, +2 or +3.
Which version these numbers belong to
- The Restoration of Erathia (1999) and the HD Edition (2015): the guide's game. Everything above.
- Armageddon's Blade, The Shadow of Death and the Complete Edition: neither expansion manual restates the formula (both read Nov 12, 2026), so Vi.ki has no official figure to confirm that the 5% and 2% steps were left alone.
- Horn of the Abyss (fan-made, unofficial): its changelog, read Nov 12, 2026, records a new Ballista damage formula and changed creature and hero figures, and nowhere states the Attack and Defense steps.
- The 2027 Remake: Ubisoft has published no damage numbers. It has said the team "preserved the original gameplay framework" and worked "to maintain the pacing and balance that veteran players know" (Ubisoft on Steam, Aug 27, 2026).
Sources
- Heroes of Might and Magic III: Prima's Official Strategy Guide, Prima Publishing, 1999 (pp.14, 17, 19, 128-129, 165, 167-169), read Nov 12, 2026
- Heroes of Might and Magic III: Armageddon's Blade manual, The 3DO Company, 1999, read Nov 12, 2026
- Heroes of Might and Magic III: The Shadow of Death manual, The 3DO Company, 2000, read Nov 12, 2026
- Horn of the Abyss changelog, HotA Crew, read Nov 12, 2026
- Heroes of Might and Magic III Remake news ("Welcome Back to Erathia", Aug 27, 2026), Ubisoft on Steam
- Heroes 3 best skills, Alex_The_Magician, Feb 23, 2020 (video)
- Heroes 3 Stats explained || Heroes 3 Stats guide || Alex_The_Magician, Alex_The_Magician, Jan 24, 2021 (video)
Moments
Heroes 3 Stats explained || Heroes 3 Stats guide || Alex_The_Magician
Alex_The_Magician
Heroes 3 best skills || Overview || Heroes 3 skills guide || Alex_The_Magician | Heroes 3 skill rank
Alex_The_Magician
See also
-
CreaturesEach of Heroes of Might and Magic 3's nine towns recruits seven levels of creatures, each with one upgrade (126 town creatures in the Complete game), plus neutral creatures found on the map such as golems and the Azure Dragon. Level 7 is the Archangel, Gold Dragon, Titan, Arch Devil, Ghost Dragon, Black Dragon, Ancient Behemoth, Chaos Hydra and Phoenix. -
Secondary SkillsA Heroes of Might and Magic 3 hero can learn up to eight of 28 secondary skills, from Archery to Wisdom, each at Basic, Advanced and Expert level. Skills are chosen from two offers at every level-up, or learned at Witch Huts, Universities and other map buildings; the official guide calls Wisdom a must for spellcasters.
-
CombatBattles in Heroes of Might and Magic 3 are fought on a 15 x 10 hex grid where each creature stack moves in order of Speed and attacks, shoots, waits or defends, while each hero casts one spell a round; morale can grant an extra turn, luck extra damage, and sieges add walls, arrow towers and a moat. -
Beginner's GuideTo start well in Heroes of Might and Magic 3, play the tutorial or an easy scenario, pick the town native to your starting terrain, build the Town Hall on day one and then halls or creature dwellings through week one, hire a second and third hero as scouts, keep your whole army on one main hero, and flag Sawmills and Ore Pits first. -
Best Damage SpellImplosion is the best damage spell in Heroes of Might and Magic 3, (Power x 75) + 300 at Expert Earth Magic, which is 1,050 damage at Power 10, more than twice any other single-target spell. Per spell point the level 2 Ice Bolt ties it at Power 11 and beats it above, and beats Lightning Bolt at every Power, by our arithmetic on the official guide's formulas.
-
Best Level 7 CreatureWe think the Ancient Behemoth is the best level 7 creature in Heroes of Might and Magic 3 for its gold. At 3,000 gold it has 300 health and cuts its target's Defense by 80%, and by the official damage formula an equal purse of them wins the exchange with all eight other upgraded level 7 creatures. The Archangel is the strongest single creature, the Arch Devil the worst buy.